The menu at The Original Pizza of Avenue L, INC is expansive, featuring 78 different items that highlight the best of Italian-American comfort food. Signature pizzas like the cheese pie, Sicilian, and Grandma pizza are menu staples, offering classic flavors made from fresh ingredients. Each bite reveals the expertise in crafting the perfect crust, combined with rich, savory sauces. Slices are available for those seeking a quick snack or lunch option, with prices starting around $5.59.

Vegetarians and meat lovers alike can enjoy a variety of toppings on their pies, making customization easy. Gluten-free options often delight those with dietary restrictions. The side offerings include garlic knots and salads, complementing the hearty pizzas. Whether dining in, taking away, or ordering for delivery, each meal promises the authentic tastes of Brooklyn pizza traditions adjusted for both modern convenience and pure satisfaction.